Moog Modular Historian Thom Holmes Explores Early Live Moog Modular Artists (1965-1970)
We stray from Moog recordings for this edition of the blog to document some of the early pioneers of live Moog Modular performance.
While digging through many of the clippings, news blurbs, and press releases associated with Bob Moog and his synthesizer, I sometimes find stories about the use of the early Moog Modular in concert. Ive been gathering these cases for a long time and offer them here for the Moog record. Most of these instances fall into the time period 1965-1970. They capture the use of the Moog Modular at its creative summit, prior to the widespread availability of the Minimoog.
The idea that the Moog Modular synthesizer could be used in a live performance is somewhat contrary to what people believe today. Yes, it was a complicated instrument and it sometimes behaved unpredictably, especially in its tuning. But the Moog Modular was also viewed as a remarkable combination of many audio devices with enormous potential. The available variations in patching and playing were essentially infinite.
Without further delay, I give you a partial record of early Moog Modular live performances, organized chronologically. By no means do I consider this record to be completeadditional listings and suggestions are welcomed.
August 28, 1965 – A live concert was produced at the R.A. Moog Companys small factory, the culmination of a workshop of composers and musicians. This small event was attended by participants, family, friends, and Moog employees. The program reproduced here is from this extensive Bob Moog Foundation blog documenting this event:
September 25, 1965 – Herb Deutsch, who helped Bob Moog with the original Moog design, brought his “New York Improvisation Quartet” to Town Hall in New York for a concert. This was the first major live Moog public performance.1
1967 – John Cage presented Solo for Voice 2 (1960), with Carol Plantamuras voice processed in real time using a Moog Modular. This was a piece composed for various instrumental settings in 1960, but this Moog performance was in 1967.
1967 – LaMonte Young, Drift Studies, live performances using Moog Modular oscillator modules. This work was for two or more sine wave drones played at frequencies prescribed by Young. Aware that the tuning of these oscillators would drift over time, he created a piece that made use of this phenomenon. This was the basic strategy for a series of works that he and partner Marian Zazeela produced into the 1970s. First performed at their Church Street loft in lower Manhattan in 1967, Young also lists several gallery installations including the Robert C. Scull Commission (1967); Claes and Patty Oldenburg Commission (1967); Betty Freeman Commission (1967). The work is still performed at Young and Zazeelas Dream House, but they no longer use the Moog modules.
May 15, 1967 – Donald Erb premieres Reconnaissance using two Moog synthesizers played in real-time with a chamber orchestra; Robert Moog operated the synthesizers at this Music In Our Time series performance, New York.2 It was performed again on October 4, 1967 in Los Angeles and at Expo ’67 in Montreal.3 The piece was one of the first chamber orchestra works composed for synthesizer. Interestingly, it used one prototype Moog Polyphonic Electronic Instrument and one Moog Synthesizer.
October 5, 1967 – Musica Elettronica Viva, Spacecraft, (Akademie der Kunste, Berlin, October 5, 1967). Live electronics including modular Moog. Richard Teitelbaum, modular Moog synthesizer, contact microphones, voice. He moogulated the voice of Carol Plantamura. Teitelbaum, an American, bought a synthesizer from Bob Moog and was the first to use one in Europe. The group also used a brainwave amplifier designed by Robert Moog to incorporate audible alpha wave signals as control voltages for the Moog. MEVs performances were not always well received, particularly at the more conservative venues like the Akademie der Kunste, where Curran recalls that members of the audience jumped on the stage and tried to stop the group from playing.4
March 6, 7 & 8, 1968 – John Mills-Cockell and Intersystems, an experimental arts collective that included Blake Parker, Mills-Cockell, Dik Zander, and Michael Hayden. They performed using the double-decker Duplex setup at the Art Gallery of Ontario. Parker and Mills-Cockell (with Moog) were housed in the bottom structure; Zander and Hayden were stationed on top with projectors, color wheels, and other light show materials. See related story at: http://www.moogfoundation.org/early-live-moog-modular-artists-john-mills-cockell/
April 28, 1968 – At New York club Generation, Lothar and the Hand People played and jammed songs from the forthcoming LP (Space Hymn). Paul Conley played synthesizer, and Kim King was credited with playing lead guitar, vocals, and electronic feedback. The synthesizer was described by the press as a miniature edition of the device used on the recording.
May 10, 1968 – Gershon Kingsley premiered Shabbat 68 for Today at the Temple Sharey Tifilo in East Orange, New Jersey, for live Moog, cantor, mixed choir, organ, percussion, guitar, and bass.
March 1969 – Leonard Bernstein Young People’s Concert received a lot of press at the time, which is why Im including it. But the Moog was on tape, not live. They played different versions of music by Bach. Bernstein described the program as, Its Bach switched-on, turned-on, rocked, rolled, shaken and baked.5 The program featured a recording of Wendy Carlos Switched-on Bach (only three months after its release) and interpretations of Bach by Lukas Foss and the New York Rock and Roll Ensemble. This important broadcast brought the word Moog into households across North America.
March 22, 1969 – John Mills-Cockells Moog was played live at a rock concert on March 22, 1969 at Torontos Rockpile festival, where the group Kensington Market premiered the newly recorded songs from its forthcoming album, Aardvark. This is one of the earliest live appearances of Moog Modular for a rock concert.
April 14, 1969 – John Eaton, Duet for Syn-Ket and Moog. During the heyday of tape composition in the early 1960s, Eaton hated working with tape. He was after a live performance situation and created instruments for this purpose. He invented the electronic instrument the Syn-ket with Paul Ketoff and added a Moog Modular to his repertoire while working with Bob Moog. Eaton performed on each of these electronic instruments in this concert. This piece was performed at least one other time live, on July 27, 1969. See much more about John Eaton at: http://www.moogfoundation.org/remembering-john-eaton-1935-2015/
June 14, 1969 – Party Day, National Arts Centre, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, with music provided by John Mills Cockell using the Moog Modular synthesizer.
August 28, 1969 – Herb Deutsch and Moog employee Chris Swansen were responsible for putting together a performance featuring four Moog Modulars at the Museum of Modern Art in New York. Deutsch performed Jazz in the Garden, a live Moog concert, at MoMA. This live concert featured a Moog quartet with Deutsch on monophonic Moog, Hank Jones on polyphonic Moog, Artie Doolittle, bass synthesizer, and Jim Pirone, percussion synthesizer. Composer Swansen was also featured on the program with his quartet, playing an electronic arrangement of Ooh Baby by the Free Spirits. It was during the Swansen performance that somebody watching the concert accidentally slipped on the power cord and unplugged it, abruptly stopping the performance for a few minutes. Bob Moog prepped all of the instruments and served as engineer for the concert.6
Swansen was long associated with Moog Music, taking the synthesizer on the road from 1969 to 1977. He was part resident composer and musician, technical advisor, and tour guide for Moog. Over time, he may have put together more live performances of Moog synthesizers than any other individual. In 1972, he was described as the Musical Director of the Experimental Music Studio at R. A. Moog Inc.
I know of at least 24 performances given across the country, from Briar Cliff College in Iowa, to Traverse City High School in Michigan, and dates from New Jersey to Texas, Florida to New Mexico. Many of these were combined demonstrations and concerts, often done by himself. But for some of the performances, Chris was joined by his trio members, Don Crocker (polyphonic synthesizer), Jon Weiss (mixing and modulation), and Swansen on monophonic Moog. His selections included everything from Bach, Lennon-McCartney, Simon and Garfunkel, Blood Sweat and Tears plus his own compositions.
August 31, 1969 – At Family Dog on the Great Highway, San Francisco. It was a rock club alternative to the Fillmore West, hosting many bands in the Summer of 1969 at this small venue. A group called S. F. Radical Lab’s Moog Synthesizer played on this night.
September 19-21, 1969 – S. F. Radical Lab’s Moog Synthesizer and Doug McKechnie and His Moog Synthesizer at the Family Dog on the Great Highway, San Francisco.
November 8, 1969 – Paul Bley and Annette Peacock and others performed live at Town Hall with Moog Modular. Paul Bley played some Moog keyboard while Peacock was modulating her singing voice through the Moog.
December 6, 1969 – Doug McKechnie played a Moog set during a sound-check at the Altamont Free Festival. This was the now-infamous Rolling Stones/Hells Angels show. A glimpse of the Moog (and a tiny snippet of sound) can also be seen in the Maysles film Gimme Shelter (1970) at about the 53-minute mark.7
December 26, 1969 – Bley and Peacock at Philharmonic Hall in New York City. Wired for Sound, a Moog presentation.”
January 30, 1970 – Gershon Kingsley and the First Moog Quartet played Carnegie Hall, NY. This was the first concert for this group and perhaps the first concert of any electronic music at Carnegie Hall. Organized by music promoter Sol Hurok, Kingsley and Bob Moog were instrumental in making this event happen. The appearance was influential in bringing the Moog into classical music venues, but with mixed results. After the concert, Kingsley said, “People were kind of confused about the concert. I understand, because it was just so new.”8 Moog was quoted in a press release, saying, Standard Moog synthesizers are being used, each fitted with operating mode presets enabling the musicians to change timbres instantly during performance.9
The music included arrangements of classical and popular selections plus some original music. Known for being a keen arranger, Kingsley’s program included Moog sounds plus various instrumentalists and vocalists. Kingsleys group consisted of himself, Stan Free, Eric B. Knight, and Ken Bichel, all playing portable models of the Moog Modular. Auditioning musicians for the gig was a monumental task and reportedly involved listening to 150 musicians. A tour of universities and symphonies followed Carnegie Hall and included concerts with the Boston Pops and Arthur Fiedler (and premier of Concerto Moogo, August 23, 1970); McAfee Gymnasium in Charleston, IL (January 28, 1971); Temple Music Fair, Ambler, PA (June 28, 1971); Clowes Hall, Indianapolis, IN (October 20, 1971); Eastman Theatre, Rochester, NY (April 6, 1972); Memorial Hall, Chapel Hill, NC (April 2, 1973); plus other dates that I know of with symphonies in Miami, Detroit, Munich, and Cologne.
February 19, 1970 – Gershon Kingsley, with his Moog Modular, performed at the Shabbat service performance at Temple Shearith Israel in Ridgefield, CT. Mrs. Herbert Deutsch was superintendent of the school, a discussion followed the service.
March 17, 1970 – Mike Vickers (who taught the Beatles how to use the Moog) played Berliozs Symphonie Fantastique at Royal Festival Hall, London. He was joined by Keith Emerson and Nice, who played Tchaikovskys Pathetique Symphony, although this was a pre-Emerson, Lake, and Palmer Moog performance. Vickers managed the patching and control of the Moog while Emerson played.
March 28, 1970 – Gershon Kingsley, Shabbat for Today live Moog performance, plus guitar, bass, drums. Temple Israel, Royal Oak, MI.
April 8, 1970 – Merrill Ellis, “playing the Moog synthesizer,” for a live performance of the pieces, Kaleidoscope, and Mutations. Tucson International Music Festival. Well, weve had no throwing of vegetables, said Ellis. He used one of the new Moog Modular models in a travel case, a model 1P.10 The electronic music studio he established at the University of North Texas housed a Moog Modular 1C with modifications that was given the name of E-11 by Bob Moog in recognition of Ellis.
April 12, 1970 – Carlos Carvajal. Genesis 70 at the San Francisco Opera House, inspired by Riley’s In-C, for dance. The orchestra will be augmented by a Moog Synthesizer to be heard at the San Francisco Opera House for the first time.11
April 14, 1970 – Gershon Kingsley. Live Moog performance at a Shabbat service in New York at the Park Avenue Synagogue. Most likely another performance of Shabbat for Today.12
May 12, 1970 – Gershon Kingsleys First Moog Quartet at the Boston Pops, performed Concerto Moogo, said to be world premier, plus excerpts from Handels Water Music and his own composition Popcorn. On stage, Gershon Kingsley and his Moog Quartet look like five freaky telephone operators plugging in and out and fiddling with weird dials. This televised program was widely broadcast around the country in August of 1970.13
May 15-16, 1970 – Doug McKechnie and His Moog Synthesizer at the Family Dog on the Great Highway, San Francisco.
August 5, 1970 – Dick Hyman played an early model of the Minimoog live, at the Eastman School of Music Arranger’s Holiday ’70, an extravaganza of jazz. With Chuck Mangione.14
August 8, 1970 – John Mills-Cockell played a restaurant gig in Toronto with his Moog Modular and sax player Doug Pringle. The restaurant was called, Meat and Potatoes.
August 12-16, 1970 – Bley and Peacock expanded their synthesizer arsenal to include the ARP. In August 1970, they were booked to play the Jazz Workshop for a week in Boston.
August 29, 1970 – Emerson, Lake, and Palmer Isle of Wight Festival. This might have been Emersons second live performance with a Moog. This historic appearance took place on the fourth day (Saturday) of the five-day event and showcased Emersons magnificent Moog Modular. More than 600,000 people attended the festival. It was the UK version of Woodstock and was influential for its number and variety of musical acts, ranging from country, Brazilian, rock, folk and a host of upcoming British acts.
September 5, 1970 – Sausalito Art Center Festival. Different Fur Trading Company gave a recital with their Moog and other musicians on piano, flute, harpsichord, and sax. Names associated with this included Frank Albright, Margaret Fabrizio, Patrick Gleeson, John Payne, John Vieira.
September 16-December 6, 1970- Gino Piserchio (1944-89) brought a Moog Modular to the Guggenheim Museum in New York to produce sound in the galleries. This was done for two and a half months from September 16-December 6, 1970, six hours a day. The program consisted of a variety of pieces, improvisation, and sound art. He was assisted by Bill Allen. Three concerts were also given in the first week of November (Wed, Thu, Fri evenings at 8:30). One piece, was an unusual rendering of the Star Spangled Banner. Twelve speakers will be installed on the ramps and four on the ground floor. Out of them will come conventional music such as the National Anthem and Bach preludes and Fugues, and very complex sound pieces involving the overlay of multitrack tapes and improvisations on the Moog by Piserchio.15 The object resting on the floor of Guggenheim Museum might have been a part of the current Picabia exhibition gone astray. It was a Plexiglas box enclosing a metal construction, parts of it painted a pretty blue. Actually, it was one element of a Moog synthesizer, the others being an enormous box resembling a switchboard and, at right angles to it, a double keyboard.16
Photo by David Sieg, 1971.
September 26, 1970 – Gershon Kingsley and First Moog Quartet with Chicago Symphony Orchestra at Orchestra Hall.
October 3, 1970 – Roger Ruggeri played a Moog Modular live, with the Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra, of which he was a member. This was during the second meeting of the Fine Arts Series at the University of Wisconsin-Waukesha. The Moog is a device which creates musical sounds electronically.17
November 1970 – Paul Bley acquired an ARP synthesizer and Annette Peacock continued to keep the Moog modules to modify her vocals. They took this configuration on an eventful tour of Europe in November of 1970. They traveled widely with bookings that included clubs, radio, television, and festival appearances in Amsterdam, Frankfurt, Munich. Berlin, Hanover, Amsterdam, and the United Kingdom.18 During these events, Bley and Peacock would perform but also explain the workings of the synthesizers.
November 20, 1970 – Merrill Ellis. At Baylor University School of Music, concert pieces for Moog modular at the annual Festival of 20th-Century Music, Waco, Texas.
November 21, 1970 – The Paul Bley Synthesizer Show played Haarlem,
Holland.. Annette Peacock. Using an ARP, no mention of Moog.
December 9, 1970 – Emerson, Lake and Palmer perform Pictures at an Exhibition at the Lyceum Theatre, London.
Thom Holmes is a music historian and composer specializing in the history of electronic music and recordings. He is the author of the textbook, Electronic and Experimental Music (fourth edition, Routledge 2012) and writes the blog, Noise and Notations. For his ongoing project, The Sound of Moog, he is archiving every known early recording of the Moog Modular Synthesizer.
blog: Noise and Notations
If you want to read more from Thom Holmes, please see his many fascinating historical blogs here: http://moogfoundation.
 Herb Deutsch biography, Hofstra University. http://www.hofstra.edu/Faculty/fac_profiles.cfm?id=352
 Billboard, may 20, 1967, p. 49.
 Liner notes, MUSICA ELETTRONICA VIVA, MEV 40 (19672007) 80675-2 (4CDs). © 2008 Anthology of Recorded Music, Inc. and New World Records.
 Price, Theodore. Switch it On, Mix it UpIts Bach. Akron Beacon Journal, March 30, 1969, 141.
 Stanleigh, Bertram, Moog Jazz in the Garden, Audio magazine, November 1969, p. 96
 Gershon Kingsley website, http://gershonkingsley.com/biography.html
 The Nashville Tennessean, Sunday, December 14, 1969, 16E.
 Tucson Daily Citizen, Tucson, Arizona, Saturday, March 28, 1970, 31.
 The Times, San Mateo, California, Tuesday, April 21, 1970, 19.
 The News Journal, Wilmington, Delaware, Tuesday, April 14, 1970, 23.
 Red Bluff Daily News, Red Bluff, California, Tuesday, August 18, 1970, 3.
 Democrat and Chronicle, Rochester, New York, Sunday, August 2, 1970, 96.
 Raymond Ericson, New York Times News Service as seen in The Pocono Record, Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, Thursday, October 15, 1970, 7.
 Raymond Ericson, New York Times News Service as seen in the Caller-Times, Corpus Christi, Texas, Sunday, October 18, 1970, 28.
 Waukesha Daily Freeman, Waukesha, Wisconsin, Saturday, October 3, 1970, 5.
 Billboard, 82.47 (Nov 21, 1970): 84.